Spirited but monetarily despondent schoolteacher Lucy Blake has just decided 'Mr Happily Ever After' doesn't exist and she's going to stop searching for him when Fate intervenes by sending her crashing, literally, into a devilishly handsome priest. After her swoon, Lucy plays amateur sleuth to discover the priest's true identity.
Private investigator Xavier Lamont has gone undercover as a teaching priest to investigate the theft of a painting. The last thing he needs is a feisty teacher who has him hot under his fake clerical collar doing her best to prove he's an imposter.
Faith in love and everlasting happiness on the verge of resurrecting, Lucy struggles to overcome the last of her lingering doubts before Xavier tires of his priestly charade and hightails it back to the city.